Jane Richards (PhD candidate) on An Incremental Approach to Filling Protection Gaps in Equality Rights for Persons with Disabilities (Human Rights Law Review)

"An Incremental Approach to Filling Protection Gaps in Equality Rights for Persons with Disabilities"
Jane Richards (PhD candidate)
Human Rights Law Review

Published on 15 May 2012

Abstract: The Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities (CRPD) guarantees that persons with disabilities (‘PWD’) are to be equal before and under the law. There are almost identical equality guarantees in the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms and Hong Kong's mini constitution – the Basic Law. Australia boasts similar legislative equality guarantees for PWD. The CRPD Committee has interpreted the right broadly, whereas constitutional courts have taken a proportionality approach, balancing the right to substantive equality against competing concerns. The tension between these methods of rights protection means the CRPD is being positioned as an alternative model of rights protection, but it is not an alternative mechanism for enforcement. This article calls on the Committee to modify its guidance to make suggestions to state parties as to how incremental advances in rights protection can be immediately implemented, even if in the short-term, these advances fall short of full inclusion.