Showing posts with label International dispute settlement. Show all posts
Showing posts with label International dispute settlement. Show all posts

Friday, October 24, 2025

James Fry and Maria Jose Alarcon on The centrality of riparian community interests in ICJ adjudication of bilateral water disputes (JERL)

"The centrality of riparian community interests in ICJ adjudication of bilateral water disputes"
James Fry and Maria Jose Alarcon
Journal of Energy & Natural Resources Law
Published online: September 2025

Abstract: The jurisprudence of the International Court of Justice consistently focuses on the ‘community of interest of riparian states’ when resolving its international water disputes, including those disputes of a bilateral nature. Contrary to the beliefs of some scholars, global community interests also do not feature in these cases. Using as its foundation a population census of all international water disputes before the ICJ, this article maps out how this court and its predecessor have handled these types of disputes. It suggests that non-global, riparian community interests prevail with these disputes.

Friday, February 28, 2025

Hailiang Xiong on The Legislative Adjustment of Chinese Enforcement Regulation of the International Commercial Settlement Agreement in the context of the Singapore mediation convention (JIDS)

"The Legislative Adjustment of Chinese Enforcement Regulation of the International Commercial Settlement Agreement in the context of the Singapore mediation convention"
Hailiang Xiong (LLM Graduate 2024)
Journal of International Dispute Settlement, Volume 16, Issue 1, March 2025, idae025
Published online: January 2025

Abstract: The United Nations Convention on International Settlement Agreements Resulting from Mediation has established an external legal framework for the cross-border enforcement of international commercial mediation settlement agreements. By virtue of the two-aspect institutional design, this Convention has constructed a modern mechanism for the direct enforcement of international commercial mediated settlement agreements. As one of the first signatories, China does not yet have the specific mediation legislation to conform to the Convention and cannot channel the Singapore Convention. This article discussed the dilemma of the ratification of the Singapore Convention in China from a comparative perspective and argues that China should adjust its mediation regulation by reducing the requirement of application for enforcement and limiting the judicial supervision to establish a direct enforcement mechanism following the potential international obligation under the Singapore Convention and further refine the macro mediation system.

Friday, January 24, 2025

Yi Tang on Charting a New Legal Order: ASEAN’s Arbitration Reform in Taming the “Unruly Horse” of Public Policy Exception (Chinese (Taiwan) Yearbook of International Law and Affairs)

"Charting a New Legal Order: ASEAN’s Arbitration Reform in Taming the “Unruly Horse” of Public Policy Exception"
Yi Tang (PhD Candidate)
Chinese (Taiwan) Yearbook of International Law and Affairs, Volume 41, 2023, pp. 112-156
Published online: December 2024

Abstract: In light of the critical role of arbitration in resolving international commercial disputes within the rapidly developing and integrating ASEAN economies, this study investigates the interpretation and application of the public policy exception, a major factor in the enforcement of foreign arbitral awards, across ASEAN’s diverse legal jurisdictions. It critically assesses how different ASEAN countries, each at varying stages of arbitration development, approach this exception. It highlights the differences in interpretation, with more developed jurisdictions adopting a narrower approach, contrasting with broader interpretations in less developed ones, thus revealing a correlation between a jurisdiction’s level of arbitration development and its approach to the public policy exception. This study also observes a possible trend towards greater coherence and uniformity in recent arbitration reforms across the region. Despite the challenges in harmonizing the public policy exception regionally, it argues for a uniform and narrow interpretation, aligning with international standards to enhance ASEAN’s attractiveness for cross-border business and investment.

Monday, November 18, 2024

Weixia Gu comments on Hong Kong's rising significance for international arbitration in China

"As Chinese firms expand overseas, legal spotlight turns on cross-border disputes"
Alyssa Chen
South China Morning Post
6 October 2024

Chinese enterprises setting up overseas are navigating a minefield of legal challenges, making effective dispute resolution through arbitration more crucial than ever...

International arbitration is a preferred method for resolving cross-border commercial disputes outside traditional court systems and involves parties from different jurisdictions submitting their conflicts to a neutral arbitration centre...

Experts cautioned that Chinese companies face significant hurdles in international arbitration because of limited understanding, language barriers, the selection of arbitration venues and differences in legal systems – obstacles that require additional support and guidance from the Chinese government...

Chinese firms might find themselves at a disadvantage because of differences between the civil law system they are accustomed to in China and the common law systems prevalent in many Western countries, particularly regarding the handling of document requests and evidence procedures...

In the realm of international arbitration, Hong Kong was increasingly proving to be an indispensable bridge between Chinese legal practices and global standards, leveraging its unique position under the “one country, two systems” principle, Weixia Gu said.

Hong Kong’s legal system presented multiple strengths in international arbitration, such as the robustness of its common law, a deep-seated legal culture, abundant bilingual legal talent and the judicial reasoning embedded in its case law system, according to Gu.

“The city – the only place in China practising common law – brings a wealth of case law and a distinctive legal thinking that provides significant learning opportunities for arbitration institutions in mainland China,” Gu said...

Click here to read the full text.

Monday, May 20, 2024

James Fry et al on Aristocrats in Arbitration: Did Class Affect Inter-state Arbitration Before or After the 1899 Hague Peace Conference? (Hague Journal on the Rule of Law)

"Aristocrats in Arbitration: Did Class Affect Inter-state Arbitration Before or After the 1899 Hague Peace Conference?"
James Fry, Arthur L. W. Cheung, Bryane Michael 
Hague Journal on the Rule of Law
Published online: April 2024

Abstract: This article explores whether the aristocratic status of arbitrators or disputants affected the outcome of inter-state arbitrations either before or after the 1899 Hague Peace Conference. This article takes a longue durĂ©e approach to the topic by including all inter-state arbitrations between 1794 and 1989. The research shows a statistically significant relationship between respondent-appointed aristocratic arbitrators on a tribunal and the outcome against the aristocratic party, as well as a statistically significant relationship between no respondent-appointed aristocratic arbitrators and outcome in favor of the claimant, but only in inter-state arbitrations before the Conference for both of these relationships. This article brings into question whether aristocratic arbitrators from before the Conference were fully committed to the international rule of law. Moreover, it highlights how such arbitrators stopped making their decisions based on class after the Conference, which should reassure users of inter-state arbitration that worry about such biases.